New figures reveal stark contrasts in how patients across the Stirling area rate the overall care they receive from their GP practice.
The Health and Care Experience survey asked people: “Overall, how would you rate the care provided by your GP practice?”, with responses grouped as positive, neutral or negative.
At the top of the positive ratings is Edenkiln Surgery in Strathblane, where 96.3 per cent of 75 respondents said the overall care they received was good.
Doune Health Centre came second, with 93.9 per cent of 107 respondents giving a positive rating, followed by Orchard House Health Centre in Stirling on 91.2 per cent.
Park Avenue Medical Centre and Kippen Surgery also performed strongly, recording positive ratings of 89.8 per cent and 89.5 per cent respectively.
A number of other practices across the area also saw more than eight in ten respondents give their care a positive assessment.
These included Park Terrace Medical Practice in Stirling, Drymen Health Centre, Killin Medical Practice and Dunblane Medical Practice.
How is your GP ranked? Use our interactive table below to find out
However, the results also reveal some less favourable experiences among patients.
Alba Medical Group in Bannockburn has the lowest positive rating of any practice in the survey, with just 38.2 per cent of 55 respondents saying their overall care was good.
That means fewer than four in ten patients surveyed gave the practice a positive verdict.
It also has the highest proportion of negative responses, with 30.9 per cent of respondents rating their care unfavourably.
Fallin Health Centre has the next-highest share of negative ratings, at 19.5 per cent of 96 respondents, while Viewfield Medical Practice in Stirling records 14.8 per cent.
Tor Medical Group in Plean is next, with 10.9 per cent of 95 respondents giving a negative assessment.
The figures are based on responses from patients rather than everyone registered with each practice, and the number of people taking part varies between surgeries.
The results should therefore be viewed as a snapshot of patient experience rather than a definitive assessment of every GP practice.
Nevertheless, they provide an insight into how patients across the Stirling area feel about the care they receive, with significant differences between individual surgeries.
GP practices in the Stirling area ranked by positive ratings for overall care
- Edenkiln Surgery – Strathblane – 96.3% positive (75 responses)
- Doune Health Centre – Doune – 93.9% positive (107 responses)
- Orchard House Health Centre – Stirling – 91.2% positive (97 responses)
- Park Avenue Medical Centre – Stirling – 89.8% positive (105 responses)
- Kippen Surgery – Kippen – 89.5% positive (83 responses)
- Park Terrace Medical Practice – Stirling – 85.9% positive (88 responses)
- Drymen Health Centre – Drymen – 85.7% positive (75 responses)
- Killin Medical Practice – Killin – 85.2% positive (84 responses)
- Dunblane Medical Practice – Dunblane – 84.8% positive (95 responses)
- Balfron Health Centre – Balfron – 84.4% positive (82 responses)
- Airthrey Park Medical Centre – Stirling – 84.3% positive (64 responses)
- Allan Park Medical Practice – Stirling – 84.1% positive (83 responses)
- Killearn Health Centre – Killearn – 83.4% positive (89 responses)
- Bridge of Allan Health Centre – Bridge of Allan – 79.5% positive (89 responses)
- Callander Medical Practice – Callander – 76.8% positive (86 responses)
- Tor Medical Group – Plean – 76.2% positive (95 responses)
- Aberfoyle & Buchlyvie Medical Centres – Buchlyvie – 74.8% positive (85 responses)
- Fallin Health Centre – Fallin – 65.1% positive (96 responses)
- Viewfield Medical Practice – Stirling – 57.9% positive (95 responses)
- Alba Medical Group – Bannockburn – 38.2% positive (55 responses)
GP practices in the Stirling area ranked by negative ratings for overall care
- Alba Medical Group – Bannockburn – 30.9% negative (55 responses)
- Fallin Health Centre – Fallin – 19.5% negative (96 responses)
- Viewfield Medical Practice – Stirling – 14.8% negative (95 responses)
- Tor Medical Group – Plean – 10.9% negative (95 responses)
- Killin Medical Practice – Killin – 8.7% negative (84 responses)
- Aberfoyle & Buchlyvie Medical Centres – Buchlyvie – 8.0% negative (85 responses)
- Bridge of Allan Health Centre – Bridge of Allan – 7.8% negative (89 responses)
- Dunblane Medical Practice – Dunblane – 6.8% negative (95 responses)
- Balfron Health Centre – Balfron – 6.7% negative (82 responses)
- Drymen Health Centre – Drymen – 5.5% negative (75 responses)
- Callander Medical Practice – Callander – 4.9% negative (86 responses)
- Airthrey Park Medical Centre – Stirling – 4.7% negative (64 responses)
- Allan Park Medical Practice – Stirling – 4.2% negative (83 responses)
- Orchard House Health Centre – Stirling – 4.1% negative (97 responses)
- Killearn Health Centre – Killearn – 4.0% negative (89 responses)
- Park Avenue Medical Centre – Stirling – 1.9% negative (105 responses)
- Park Terrace Medical Practice – Stirling – 1.7% negative (88 responses)
- Doune Health Centre – Doune – 1.3% negative (107 responses)
- Kippen Surgery – Kippen – 0.8% negative (83 responses)
Share