Study reveals widespread misunderstandings about UK dog laws

3
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A new study has revealed that the public may be overestimating the legal protections in place for dogs.

The research, led by Sarah Weir from the University of Stirling’s Faculty of Natural Sciences and involving more than 1,700 people across the UK, found that most people lack a clear understanding of dog laws and commonly believe that stronger safeguards exist for dogs than are currently in place.

Sarah Weir, a psychologist and lead author of the study, said: "These findings challenge common assumptions about legal awareness and responsible ownership, showing that while dog owners are often expected to understand and comply with the law, they are no more accurate in their knowledge than non-owners.

"This raises concerns about how legal understanding can be improved when people are unaware their knowledge is inaccurate."

Lead researcher Sarah Weir of the University’s Faculty of Natural Sciences (Image: University of Stirling)

Dog owners, the study found, tended to be more confident in their answers about legal matters than non-owners, but their answers were not more accurate.

The research was carried out through a representative survey of 1,758 adults across the UK.

Participants were asked about their knowledge of 22 current, nation specific, and hypothetical dog laws.

The results were analysed using multinomial statistical models, which classify answers into categories such as correct, incorrect, or unsure and look for trends across different demographic groups.

While most respondents correctly identified well-publicised rules such as those related to dog fouling and banned breeds, the study uncovered several widespread misconceptions.

The nationally representative study assessed participants’ knowledge of 22 dog-related laws—current, nation-specific, and hypothetical (Image: University of Stirling)

A significant 85 per cent of participants wrongly believed that aversive training methods are already illegal in the UK, and only 16 per cent were aware that there is no law explicitly banning the euthanasia of healthy dogs.

More than half of those surveyed did not know that shock collars are only banned in Wales and not across the entire UK.

Fewer than half understood that it is illegal for a dog to cause fear or apprehension in a person within a private home.

Ms Weir said differences in legal knowledge may reflect broader social changes.

She said: "Younger participants were more likely to assume that stronger legal protections for dogs and owners already existed, which may reflect the increasingly elevated status of dogs in society.

"Many people nowadays increasingly view their dogs as more like family members or children than was historically the case."

She explained that expectations around dog welfare and regulation appear to reflect wider societal attitudes, not just those of dog owners.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos