New Stirling study finds reducing wild fish in salmon feed has come at an environmental cost.
Led by the University of Stirling's Institute of Aquaculture, the research has revealed that cutting down on marine ingredients in aquafeed has caused a sharp rise in greenhouse gas emissions, land use, and water consumption in European aquaculture over the past two decades.
The research, co-authored by Björn Kok and Dr Wesley Malcorps, explores the environmental trade-offs of replacing fishmeal and fish oil with plant-based alternatives in fish feed.
Björn Kok, lead author of the study, said: "Reducing dependence on marine resources has been treated as the main environmental sustainability goal in aquaculture.
"However, if environmental sustainability assessments focus on a single headline metric, they risk telling an incomplete, and sometimes misleading, story.
"We need a comprehensive view on environmental sustainability."
Lead author Bjorn Kok (Image: University of Stirling)
The study found that between 2000 and 2020 the European aquaculture industry reduced its use of wild-caught fish in feed by 13 per cent even as the sector nearly doubled in size.
This growth was largely fuelled by the expansion of Atlantic salmon farming in Norway, but the study states that it has come with serious environmental repercussions.
The use of plant-based ingredients such as soy protein concentrate and rapeseed oil, both of which have a high environmental impact, was found to contribute heavily to the increased footprint.
The study reported a 314 per cent rise in greenhouse gas emissions, a 594 per cent increase in land use, and a 236 per cent jump in water consumption linked to these changes in feed composition.
Marine eutrophication, which refers to the build-up of nutrients leading to harmful algal blooms, rose by 630 per cent, while freshwater eutrophication climbed by 468 per cent.
The researchers used Index Decomposition Analysis to pinpoint the factors behind these increases, separating the impacts of production growth, feed efficiency, and ingredient changes.
Dr Wesley Malcorps, co-lead author and research fellow at the University of Stirling’s Institute of Aquaculture, said: "We need to make better use of what we already have, such as fish processing by-products, which are rich in nutrients and have a low environmental footprint.
"Novel ingredients show potential to support long-term industry growth, but they still face challenges around inconsistent quality, limited supply, and high costs.
"At their current stage of development and scale, they have yet to deliver the environmental sustainability performance many expected."
When measured per kilogram of fish farmed in Europe, wild fish use fell by 59 per cent over the 20-year period.
However, this was counterbalanced by a 103 per cent rise in greenhouse gas emissions, a 336 per cent increase in land use, and a 65 per cent uptick in water consumption.
Marine eutrophication was up by 285 per cent and freshwater eutrophication by 167 per cent.
The study also concluded that factors such as the type of fish being farmed and feed conversion rates had little influence on the overall environmental impact compared to the composition of the feed itself.
Researchers hope their findings will guide more balanced decision-making in the industry.
The study, titled Sustainable Aquafeed? The Devil is in the Detail, was conducted in collaboration with Blue Food Performance Ltd, the University of Zurich, and Utrecht University.
Share