Experts find Tobacco industry trying to derail smoking legislation

4
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Study finds the tobacco industry is still using tactics to undermine regulations.

Experts at the University of Stirling warn that these are the same tactics used two decades ago to try to weaken Scotland’s landmark smoking ban.

The warning comes as Scotland marks 20 years since its smoke-free legislation came into force, banning smoking in all enclosed public places and workplaces from March 26, 2006.

The ban faced intense opposition from the tobacco industry, which tried to derail or weaken the proposals by proposing loopholes.

Dr Rachel O’Donnell, associate professor at the University of Stirling’s Institute for Social Marketing and Health (ISMH), said: "This report has important lessons for today – the UK is on the cusp of another huge, world-leading leap in tobacco control.

Dr Rachel O'Donnell (Image: University of Stirling)

"The Tobacco and Vapes Bill currently passing through the Westminster parliament will mean those turning 18 at the beginning of 2027 will never be able to purchase tobacco, and there will be further powers to extend smoke-free spaces under devolved health legislation.

"These are bold measures that will help tackle the burden that tobacco still places on our communities, and yet we see many of the tobacco industry tactics described in our Unwelcome Guest report from 2005 being used again to limit the vision and scope of the Tobacco and Vapes Bill from the outset."

The tobacco industry is now focusing its efforts on the Tobacco and Vapes Bill, which is currently progressing through Westminster.

The proposed legislation would make it illegal to sell tobacco products to anyone born on or after January 1, 2009.

It was last year backed by MPs in March, then endorsed by MSPs in May, and is now under consideration in the House of Lords.

Lord McConnell of Glenscorrodale, who was First Minister when Scotland introduced its smoking ban and now serves as Chancellor of the University of Stirling, is among those reviewing the legislation.

Lord McConnell (Image: Roger Harris)

Lord McConnell said: "The ban on indoor smoking in public places was the moment when the Scottish Parliament came of age.

"We saved lives, transformed Scotland’s hospitality culture, and we won public support despite the ferocious campaign against the ban.

"It was legislation and implementation at its best."

The original 2005 report by ASH Scotland, The Unwelcome Guest: How Scotland invited the tobacco industry to smoke outside, documented industry interference in the lead-up to the 2006 law.

It has been republished with a new foreword to mark the legislation’s upcoming 20th anniversary in 2026.

Professor Sean Semple of the University of Stirling’s ISMH said: "The smoke-free legislation of 2006 changed how the nation perceived the acceptability of smoking in the same space as non-smokers.

"Scotland has made great progress, but we still have a long way to go in protecting our people from the harms of second-hand smoke.

"Recent data suggests that about one in five non-smoking adults breathe unwanted tobacco smoke on any given day.

"This report highlights the need for us to continue to provide more smoke-free spaces and guard against tobacco industry interference in us making that progress."

Sheila Duffy, Chief Executive, ASH Scotland (Image: University of Stirling)

Sheila Duffy, chief executive of ASH Scotland and a co-author of the new foreword, said: "This report spotlights corporate interference tactics that deepen social injustice.

"The tobacco and nicotine industry continues to generate huge profits by promoting addictive, health-harming products at great cost to the health of people in Scotland, especially those in our poorest communities.

"A key current lesson from ASH Scotland’s Unwelcome Guest report is that Scotland’s elected representatives and policymakers need to recognise and reject interference by the tobacco industry and its allies, which distorts consultation processes and can disrupt, delay and undermine the effective regulation of tobacco and recreational nicotine products."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos