University of Stirling experts warning over alcohol laws

3
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Plans to overhaul alcohol licensing laws have sparked warnings of regulatory capture and threats to public health.

In a new editorial published in the journal Addiction, experts at the University of Stirling Institute of Social Marketing and Health warned that the proposed changes to licensing in England and Wales could undermine already limited democratic accountability.

The changes, backed by the UK Government, were recommended following a quickly produced report by the Licensing Taskforce made up largely of hospitality industry figures.

Their proposals include shifting the primary goal of licensing from public protection to economic enablement, expanding the powers of unelected licensing officers and reducing the oversight of elected local committees.

Dr James Nicholls (Image: University of Stirling)

Dr James Nicholls, senior lecturer in public health at Stirling and lead author of the paper, said: “The Taskforce Report aims to fundamentally reframe the purposes of alcohol licensing in England and Wales: moving from public protection to the promotion of private business interests.

“Conducted at speed, with minimal public scrutiny, systematically excluding health considerations and dominated by commercial interests, it constitutes a clear case of regulatory capture.

“This should be resisted by anyone with an interest in fair and effective governance, as well as a concern for effectively preventing harm.”

The Taskforce was launched in April 2025 by the Treasury and co-chaired by a government minister and the CEO of pub and brewing company Greene King.

It also included representatives from UK Hospitality and the Night Time Industries Association but did not involve the Department of Health and Social Care.

Professor Niamh Fitzgerald, director of ISMH and co-author of the paper, said: “The system by which licences are granted is a matter of public concern, since the impacts of alcohol are felt by communities, families and society at large.

“The proposals are presented as being about hospitality businesses, but the measures would inevitably weaken local authority powers to regulate off-trade sales, leading to higher numbers of shops and warehouses offering cheap alcohol and 24-hour home deliveries.

“This will do nothing to help hospitality businesses but worsen recent trends away from drinking in bars.

“More drinking means more ambulance calls, antisocial behaviour and ever-higher numbers of people dying as a result.”

Professor Niamh Fitzgerald (Image: University of Stirling)

The UK Government’s response, published in June, supported the Taskforce’s recommendations and pledged to explore the implementation of its core recommendations and establish a new Licensing Working Group embedded within an industry-led council.

Dr Nicholls added: “The Minister’s framing of alcohol retail as a source of happiness and social cohesion is also concerning, as the language would violate industry marketing codes if used in commercial advertising.

“There must be greater transparency, independent oversight and meaningful public consultation before any reforms are implemented.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos